7 Safe Caribbean Islands + 10 Where Scams Are Common

Planning a Caribbean getaway means choosing between paradise and potential problems. While many islands offer picture-perfect beaches and welcoming locals, others have developed reputations for tourist scams.

Understanding which destinations prioritize visitor safety can make the difference between a dream vacation and a stressful experience. This guide highlights both the safest havens and places where you’ll need to keep your wits about you.

1. Cayman Islands

Pristine beaches and crystal waters aren’t the only draws to this British Overseas Territory. The Cayman Islands maintain strict safety standards and enjoy a reputation for being virtually crime-free for tourists.

Well-developed infrastructure and a focus on upscale tourism create an environment where visitors can relax completely. The islands’ economic prosperity contributes to overall stability, making it a worry-free destination year-round.

2. Bonaire

Divers and nature enthusiasts flock to this peaceful haven known for its remarkable marine conservation. Bonaire offers a refreshingly laid-back atmosphere where crime rarely touches the tourist experience.

The small population and focus on eco-tourism rather than mass tourism helps maintain the island’s safe character. Visitors can explore coral reefs, windsurf, or hike with minimal concerns about personal safety.

3. Turks And Caicos

Luxury meets tranquility on these breathtaking islands where safety is taken seriously. Turks and Caicos maintains a strong security presence around tourist areas without feeling intrusive or overwhelming.

The high-end nature of most accommodations means good lighting, security staff, and well-maintained properties. Visitors consistently report feeling secure while enjoying the spectacular beaches and water activities throughout the archipelago.

4. St. Kitts And Nevis

Warm smiles greet visitors throughout these lush volcanic islands where community ties run deep. St. Kitts and Nevis prioritizes tourism safety through community policing and strong local connections.

The relatively small size of these islands means visitors are rarely anonymous, creating natural safety through familiarity. Most tourist activities center around well-established areas where both locals and visitors share beautiful spaces without tension.

5. Barbados

Reliable infrastructure and excellent healthcare options set this island apart from many Caribbean destinations. Barbados maintains strong safety standards while offering authentic cultural experiences beyond resort walls.

The island’s stable government and economy contribute to overall security for visitors. Tourist police specifically patrol popular areas, and most locals understand that their livelihood depends on visitors feeling comfortable and returning.

6. Anguilla

Exclusive and tranquil beaches define this tiny gem where violent crime is virtually nonexistent. Anguilla’s small population and focus on luxury tourism create a naturally safe environment for travelers seeking peace.

The island’s limited access points (mainly by boat or small aircraft) help control who comes and goes. Visitors can wander pristine beaches and explore local villages without the wariness that might be necessary elsewhere.

7. Aruba

This sun-drenched paradise boasts one of the lowest crime rates in the Caribbean region. Aruba’s strong tourism focus means well-lit streets, reliable police presence, and locals who understand the importance of visitor safety.

The island’s stable political climate and strong ties to the Netherlands contribute to its excellent safety record. Most travelers report feeling completely at ease, even when exploring beyond resort areas.

8. Jamaica

Tourist hotspots often attract those looking to make quick money through deception. Jamaica’s popularity brings wonderful experiences but also requires awareness of common scams like inflated taxi fares and pressure to buy goods.

Outside resort compounds, visitors may encounter persistent vendors or unofficial guides. The contrast between resort areas and surrounding communities can be stark, making it important to arrange activities through reputable companies.

9. Dominican Republic

All-inclusive resorts dominate the landscape where price manipulation often targets unsuspecting visitors. The Dominican Republic offers stunning beaches and vibrant culture, but travelers report frequent issues with unexpected charges and service misrepresentations.

Motorcycle taxis may overcharge tourists, and some excursion operators don’t deliver what they advertise. Still, millions visit annually, enjoying beautiful beaches while learning to verify prices before agreeing to services.

10. The Bahamas

Cruise ships dock daily, creating perfect opportunities for scammers near popular ports. The Bahamas’ beauty is undeniable, but so is the prevalence of tourist-targeted schemes, especially in Nassau and Freeport.

Visitors often encounter unlicensed tour guides offering “special deals” that don’t materialize. Jet ski rentals can lead to disputes over damage that wasn’t there, and some shops dramatically mark up prices when cruise ships are in port.

11. Haiti

Economic challenges create an environment where visitors may face persistent solicitation. Haiti’s incredible cultural heritage and resilient spirit attract adventurous travelers, but the country’s poverty can lead to desperate measures.

Unofficial “guides” may approach offering services then demand payment. Some travelers report being charged “special taxes” that don’t exist. Despite these challenges, respectful visitors who connect with legitimate tour operators can have meaningful experiences.

12. Puerto Rico

Vibrant nightlife and beautiful beaches come with urban scams in certain areas. Puerto Rico offers American familiarity with Caribbean flair, but San Juan’s tourist districts see their share of schemes targeting visitors.

Credit card skimming occurs at some establishments, and taxi drivers might take longer routes to increase fares. Despite these concerns, most travelers have wonderful experiences, especially when staying alert in crowded areas and using reputable businesses.

13. Trinidad And Tobago

Carnival celebrations bring excitement along with opportunistic scammers looking for distracted tourists. Trinidad and Tobago’s vibrant culture and festivities create unforgettable experiences, but also opportunities for pickpocketing and overcharging.

Unauthorized tour guides may approach offering “exclusive” experiences at inflated prices. During major festivals, some accommodations dramatically increase rates without notice. Savvy travelers enjoy these islands by booking through established companies and staying vigilant in crowds.

14. St. Lucia

Lush mountainous landscapes attract adventure seekers who sometimes encounter misleading tour offers. St. Lucia’s stunning scenery draws visitors year-round, but its popularity has led to some questionable business practices targeting tourists.

Unlicensed beach vendors may pressure visitors to purchase goods or services. Some excursion operators advertise experiences that don’t match reality. Despite these concerns, most travelers have wonderful experiences when booking through their resorts or established companies.

15. Antigua And Barbuda

Cruise ship arrivals signal opportunity for those selling “authentic” souvenirs with questionable origins. Antigua and Barbuda offer 365 gorgeous beaches, but the main port area sees various schemes targeting day visitors.

Jewelry stores might misrepresent the value or authenticity of items. Some taxi drivers quote one price then demand more upon arrival. Most visitors still enjoy these beautiful islands, especially when researching fair prices beforehand.

16. St. Maarten

Divided sovereignty creates confusion that opportunists sometimes exploit through currency manipulation. St. Maarten/St. Martin’s unique Dutch/French split offers two cultures on one island, but also complicates pricing and services.

Some businesses charge “conversion fees” when accepting different currencies. Beach chair rentals might start at one price but include unexpected “extras.” Despite these issues, the island remains popular for its beautiful beaches and duty-free shopping.

17. Cuba

Complex currency systems and state-controlled tourism create unique opportunities for misunderstandings and overcharging. Cuba’s fascinating culture and history attract visitors despite restrictions, but navigating its economic system can be challenging.

Tourists often encounter dual pricing far higher than local rates. Some casa particular owners advertise amenities that don’t exist. Despite these challenges, travelers who research thoroughly and learn basic Spanish typically report meaningful, authentic experiences.