17 Caribbean Islands Where Tourists Keep Getting Scammed

A Caribbean getaway sounds like a dream come true, but even in paradise, there are pitfalls to avoid. Overpriced souvenirs, misleading tour guides, and hidden charges are just a few of the scams that can turn your vacation sour.
With so many beautiful islands to explore, it’s important to be aware of these traps to make the most of your trip. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the top 17 Caribbean islands where tourists are often caught in scams.
By staying informed, you’ll be able to enjoy the beauty and culture of the Caribbean without falling for common tourist traps.
1. Bahamas

If you find yourself in the Bahamas, be cautious with street vendors. Often, tourists are tricked into paying exorbitant prices for counterfeit goods. It’s a common issue here. Sometimes, the friendly demeanor of the sellers can mask their real intentions.
Have you ever wondered why that local craft seems overpriced? It’s likely a scam. Always ensure you negotiate prices before making any purchase. Moreover, pay attention to currency exchanges. Scammers often target visitors unfamiliar with local rates, offering unfavorable conversions.
In Nassau, be wary of taxi drivers overcharging by taking longer routes. Hence, agree on fares beforehand.
2. Dominican Republic

In the Dominican Republic, ‘authentic’ cigars are a common scam. Vendors often sell fake cigars to unsuspecting tourists. This scam thrives in crowded areas.
Have you been offered a cigar that seems unusually cheap? It’s probably counterfeit. Always purchase from established shops and avoid street sellers. Similarly, be cautious of friendly locals offering ‘free’ services, only to demand a tip later.
Santo Domingo is notorious for taxi drivers claiming their meters are broken. Always settle on a fare before starting your journey to avoid disputes.
3. Jamaica

When in Jamaica, be wary of ‘special’ tours offered by seemingly friendly locals. Often, these excursions turn out to be overpriced or non-existent. It’s a hustle many fall for.
Are you tempted by a deal that sounds too good to be true? Most likely, it is. Ensure you book tours through reputable agencies. Many tourists have lost money on phantom tours that end up being mere walks on the beach.
It’s not uncommon for taxi drivers in Kingston to demand extra fees mid-journey. Always confirm the route and price before setting off.
4. Puerto Rico

In Puerto Rico, ticket scams are rampant near major attractions. Scammers sell fake tickets to eager tourists. It’s a disappointment many face.
When did you last verify a ticket’s authenticity? Always buy them from official counters or online platforms. Additionally, be cautious of timeshare presentations promising free gifts. Often, these are lengthy sales pitches with no real benefit.
In San Juan, be alert for unofficial tour guides offering historical walks. They frequently charge exorbitant fees for misleading information.
5. Cayman Islands

Cayman Islands offer beautiful beaches, but scams exist. Overpriced water sports are a common issue for tourists. It’s a frequent frustration.
Have you ever confirmed water sport rates before participating? Always check prices and services offered. Similarly, be cautious of vendors promising exclusive deals on equipment rentals.
In George Town, be wary of souvenir shops selling fake luxury goods to unsuspecting tourists. Stick to recognized stores for authentic purchases.
6. Saint Lucia

Saint Lucia is known for its picturesque landscapes, but scams lurk everywhere. Many tourists encounter currency exchange scams here. It’s an easy mistake to make.
When was the last time you calculated an exchange rate? Always use official exchange services and avoid street deals. Furthermore, be wary of overly enthusiastic guides offering ‘exclusive’ tours that end up being generic.
In Castries, keep an eye out for taxi drivers taking advantage of tourists by inflating fares. Agree on a price before starting your journey.
7. Haiti

Though Haiti offers vibrant markets, scams are prevalent. Tourists often pay inflated prices for local crafts. It’s an issue that catches many off guard.
Where did you last haggle for a fair price? Always negotiate assertively and check multiple vendors before buying. Furthermore, beware of locals offering unsolicited help with luggage, expecting hefty tips.
Port-au-Prince is notorious for scams involving fake travel agents. Ensure you verify credentials and book through reputable sources to secure genuine services.
8. Trinidad and Tobago

During festivals, Trinidad and Tobago become hive for scams. Fake event tickets are a common issue. It’s a hassle many tourists face.
How often do you verify ticket sources? Always purchase from official vendors and be wary of street sellers. Moreover, be cautious of people offering ‘VIP’ experiences at inflated prices.
In Port of Spain, be alert for unofficial taxis that may charge exorbitant rates. Opting for registered taxis ensures safer and fairer travel.
9. Guadeloupe

Guadeloupe’s markets are vibrant, but scams are prevalent. Fake currency exchanges often trick tourists, especially in busy areas. It’s a frequent issue.
When did you last verify exchange rates? Always use official services and avoid street deals. Additionally, be wary of vendors selling counterfeit souvenirs.
In Basse-Terre, be cautious of unofficial guides promising ‘unique’ experiences that are generic. Book through recognized agencies for genuine tours.
10. Aruba

Aruba’s allure often masks underlying scams. Timeshare deals are notorious here. Often, tourists are lured into lengthy presentations with little payoff.
It’s important to question every offer. Carefully read contracts and consult with locals or online reviews to gauge authenticity. Additionally, be wary of street vendors selling counterfeit jewelry.
In Oranjestad, watch out for taxi drivers who refuse to use the meter, leading to inflated fares. Always insist on meter usage or agree on a fare beforehand.
11. Cuba

Cuba is famous for cigars, but scams abound. Tourists frequently buy counterfeit cigars from street vendors. It’s a mistake many make.
Are you confident in your purchase? Always buy from reputable cigar shops. Furthermore, be aware of friendly locals who offer unsolicited assistance, only to demand tips later.
In Havana, be cautious of taxi drivers claiming the meter is broken. Agreeing on a fare before the ride prevents unexpected charges.
12. Barbados

This tropical paradise has its share of scams. On Barbados’ beaches, vendors often sell overpriced drinks to tourists. It’s a common trap many fall into.
Did you ever question why that coconut drink cost so much? Always check prices before purchasing. Similarly, watch out for locals offering overpriced jet ski rentals without proper instructions.
In Bridgetown, be cautious of tour operators who promise exclusive experiences but deliver ordinary trips. Booking through trusted agencies can save you from disappointing outings.
13. Grenada

Grenada’s spices attract many, but scams are frequent. Tourists often pay exorbitant prices for subpar products. It’s a common issue here.
Did you verify the spice quality and price? Always compare prices from multiple vendors. Moreover, be wary of ‘special’ offers that seem too good to be true.
In St. George’s, watch for tour guides overcharging by promising unique experiences that are standard. Booking through trusted agencies avoids such pitfalls.
14. Saint Kitts and Nevis

Saint Kitts and Nevis, while charming, have their scams. Tourists often encounter overpriced souvenirs. It’s a frequent trap.
Have you ever questioned the real value of that keepsake? Always haggle and compare prices across different stalls. Additionally, be cautious of taxi drivers who inflate fares for tourists.
In Basseterre, be vigilant against fake travel deals that promise luxury but deliver mediocre experiences. Double-check reviews and opt for recognized operators.
15. Antigua and Barbuda

Though Antigua and Barbuda boast stunning beaches, scams are present. Fake tour guides often target tourists, offering misleading information.
Where did you last verify a tour guide’s credentials? Always choose guides with proper identification. Additionally, be cautious of vendors selling counterfeit goods at tourist hotspots.
In St. John’s, beware of street performers who demand high tips after engaging tourists. Enjoy the show, but set your terms upfront.
16. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines

Boat tours in the Grenadines are popular but fraught with scams. Extra fees often surprise tourists post-tour. It’s a common complaint.
When did you last confirm the full tour cost? Always clarify all fees before booking. Additionally, be wary of locals offering ‘exclusive’ tours that are anything but.
In Kingstown, watch for taxi drivers who exploit tourists by taking longer routes. Confirm the destination and route beforehand.
17. Martinique

Martinique, with its French flair, often sees tourists falling for taxi scams. Drivers may refuse to use meters, overcharging unsuspecting visitors. It’s a recurring problem.
How often do you confirm meter usage? Always insist on it or agree on a fare before starting. Additionally, be cautious of street vendors selling counterfeit perfumes.
In Fort-de-France, watch for impromptu guides offering high-priced tours with little value. Opt for tours booked through legitimate services.